___ Gehrig, New York-born MLB first baseman who spent his entire career with his hometown team, the New York Yankees

"The ___ Four" (nickname for The Beatles)3 Whitey ___, New York-born MLB pitcher who spent his entire career with his hometown team, the New York Yankees4 "Mi ___" ("My love" in Spanish)4 "Ali ___ and the Forty Thieves"4 League for Shaquille O'Neal or Steph Curry: Abbr.3 "The Simpsons" neighbor Flanders3 ___ Larkin, Ohio-born MLB shortstop who spent his entire career with his hometown team, the Cincinnati Reds5 Carpet buyer's calculation4